“I don't rent to people with children,” plate 14 from Locataires Et Propriétaires by Honoré Daumier

“I don't rent to people with children,” plate 14 from Locataires Et Propriétaires 1847

0:00
0:00

Dimensions: 260 × 220 mm (image); 356 × 273 mm (sheet)

Copyright: Public Domain

Editor: So, here we have Honoré Daumier's lithograph from 1847, plate 14 from "Locataires et Propriétaires," bluntly titled, "I don't rent to people with children." It's unsettling! You’ve got this woman, probably a widow, with her son… and then this dragon lady, surrounded by her horde of lapdogs, literally shutting them down. What strikes you most about it? Curator: Ah, Daumier. Always holding up a mirror to society, even if the reflection is a bit cracked, isn’t it? For me, it's the contrast – the crisp lines defining the hopeful mother and child versus the almost feral energy radiating from the landlady. Look at the texture; the almost frenzied cross-hatching around her versus the smoother tones of the visitors. What does that tell you about where Daumier's sympathies lie? Editor: That she's… unpleasant? He makes her almost monstrous with those shading choices. It's not subtle, is it? He's hitting us over the head with her disdain, all those dogs fighting for her affection and the stark contrast between her apparent wealth and her closed-off heart. I'm just trying to parse out the actual message in that romantic style: the idea that something as human and simple as needing a place to live is seen as disruptive... that’s hard. Curator: Exactly! It's a caricature, of course, but rooted in very real social anxieties of the time. Think of Paris then – overcrowded, rapidly changing… land at a premium. And suddenly, the presence of a child isn't seen as a blessing, but a liability. A financial risk! Does it change how you perceive the piece when you see it as less about individual nastiness, and more about a systemic problem? Editor: Absolutely. It moves beyond just ‘mean landlady’ to a commentary about economic pressures and the dehumanization of people… a commentary on today’s landscape. So even a comedic representation, like this, reveals how something seemingly personal is embedded in the fabric of politics and culture? Curator: Precisely. Art reflects and refracts life. This print? A darkly humorous glimpse into a very real struggle, still playing out, perhaps, even now.

Show more

Comments

No comments

Be the first to comment and join the conversation on the ultimate creative platform.