Portret van Dost Mahomed, een landbezitter en stamhoofd uit Sindh before 1872

Curator: Here we have a striking photographic portrait. It's titled "Portret van Dost Mahomed, een landbezitter en stamhoofd uit Sindh" which translates to "Portrait of Dost Mahomed, a landowner and chieftain from Sindh," dating to before 1872. Editor: It’s remarkably stark. The oval frame within the larger page feels very contained. All tonal, with a great focus on texture in the fabrics and especially his beard. There's an incredible presence, a certain stoicism. Curator: Tanner captured a figure of considerable influence within a colonial framework. Sindh, now part of Pakistan, was then under British control. Think about how portraiture functions here. Editor: It really makes you consider what this image was made for. The materials must have been difficult to manage, the subject, well that's a different kind of material. Photography wasn't some neutral, objective recording. Curator: Precisely. It's about constructing an image within power dynamics, even reinforcing Orientalist tropes. Consider his attire, how it might be viewed. Not necessarily ethnographic, yet potentially feeding into such a perception for a Western audience. Editor: You see the labor involved. Not just of the sitter and photographer but the chemical processes that were crucial. This wasn't mass production; it has the touch of a maker throughout. The subdued palette makes me consider how that was developed in early photographic materials. Curator: The gaze he returns confronts assumptions embedded in colonial viewpoints. It prompts questions about representation, who holds the power to portray whom, and for what purpose. Editor: For me, this shows an intimate picture into the labour conditions within the discipline. Curator: Ultimately, I feel this photograph encourages critical reflection on the gaze, power, and the complicated legacies of colonial representation in early photography. Editor: Agreed. Seeing how early methods transform something complex into an accessible form leaves us thinking about how things come into existence even in photographic images such as this one.