" . . . We have given no one the right to doubt the sincerity of our actions . . . " c. 19th century

Editor: This is a print by Paul Gavarni, and the title is a bit of a mouthful: " . . . We have given no one the right to doubt the sincerity of our actions . . . ". What strikes me is the contrast between the woman reading intently and the man seemingly dozing beside her. What's your take on it? Curator: Consider the material reality: lithography allowed Gavarni to mass-produce and disseminate social commentary widely. This print, appearing in a journal, becomes a commodity, reflecting the rise of print culture and its consumption by a growing middle class. The labor involved in creating and distributing such images is crucial. Editor: So, the act of making and selling it is part of the message? Curator: Precisely. The medium isn't just a vehicle; it's embedded in the social and economic fabric Gavarni is depicting and critiquing. We must reflect on the labor and materiality involved, always. Editor: That definitely gives me a new perspective to consider. Thanks!